Page 1 of 5

Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 16:19
by dogbot
Alright fellas.

Any experience based words of advice on half-shell helmets? This sort of thing:

Image

Any brands to try, avoid, etc would be appreciated.

Oh, and you're welcome to say "don't" and so on, but be prepared to be paid no attention to. ;)

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 16:22
by Kwacky
You want the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle site.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 16:26
by dogbot
A bad choice. But I might be a turtle, for all you really know, Mr Kwacky... ;)

It doesn't matter what helmet you choose, there'll always be someone to tell you why it's wrong.

I once wrote a blog about buying a new Arai (no advice requested) and some halfwit spent days explaining to me why I should get a Shoei - basically because Mickey Dunlop wears them, so if he likes them, they must be good. Err, I think you'll find that they pay him for his endorsement, pal.

Would it have sounded better if I'd said "Motorcycle helmets in the style of a German M1940" or similar?

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 16:28
by dogbot
I should just say **** it and get a Prussian Pickelhaus...

Image

8) :D

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 17:16
by Kwacky
Now that's got style. Not very practical but stylish all the same.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 17:21
by D6
What about a Viking one with 2 horns.

No experience at all with open face helmets

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 18:17
by TonyB
I'm all for 'to each his own' but to me it looks like the kind of receptacle they'd use to carry around the bits of scooped up face should you have an accident in one.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 18:54
by dogbot
You gonna live forever or die trying, huh?

They all have British standards kite marks and are legal. Loads of people wear 'em. Full face lid and a cruiser just doesn't work for me.

Also, see last paragraph of OP. :)

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 18:55
by dogbot
Kwacky wrote:Now that's got style. Not very practical but stylish all the same.
Also good for Kamikaze runs into truculent motorists... :D
D6 wrote:What about a Viking one with 2 horns.

No experience at all with open face helmets
My ex used to wear one of those to festivals. So... no. ]:)

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 20:30
by duke63
Image

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 20:30
by duke63
Image

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 21:14
by Rossgo
I have no advice here. But personally I don't like them. I would feel very worried if I came off. As an image fair enough, stand by the bike etc but if the worst was too happen while riding then it offers nothing for the protection of the face which is silly in my opinion.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 21:45
by Kwacky
He needs a full face lid for safety reasons - the public don't need to see his face (lol)

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 23:30
by Blade
Is the helmet you suggest road legal Dogbot ?

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 25 Jan 2016, 23:31
by Blade
duke63 wrote:Image
Is that ACU approved Duke ?

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 26 Jan 2016, 00:12
by StMarks
duke63 wrote:Image
I actually like that. ^

In answer to your OP Dogbot, I think the first lid you posted up would look very in keeping with your new bike.
However, fwiw, I strongly believe that helmets must be fit for purpose.
I expect that you've had a few offs in your time.? Well, I certainly have. If helmets were not compulsory there is a chance that I would have elected to ride without a lid a good number of times. What I can say without any doubt is that I would 100% definitely not be here to write this without the protection afforded to me by a crash helmet.
So IMHO if you want a helmet that completes the image, and that is an overriding factor, then that is entirely your prerogative. However do make sure that it meets type approval.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 26 Jan 2016, 09:07
by Blade
Totally agree St Marks.

This picture doesn't need any words.

Image

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 26 Jan 2016, 14:17
by D6
Blade wrote:Totally agree St Marks.

This picture doesn't need any words.

Image

How did that happen? He must have skidded doing a headstand for ages.

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 26 Jan 2016, 14:20
by DaytonAndy
Or got dragged by something (tmi)

Re: Half Shell Helmets

Posted: 26 Jan 2016, 15:09
by StMarks
D6 wrote: ...How did that happen? He must have skidded doing a headstand for ages.
Fwiw I've ground through the outer on a helmet, and that was just surfing tarmac with the forehead area of my lid as one of my contact points (I remember actually pushing down with my head to take some pressure off my left hand because I could feel my glove disintegrating).
I don't still have that helmet, & no pictures either (pre' mobile phone cameras era) & whist it was no where as dramatic as Blade's illustration it made a similar point.
I would expect that if your bike ended on top of you as you slid down the tarmac, it would take mere moments for the extra pressure to make that sort of reduction. Once the shell is through, I imagine that the lining will offer very little resistance.?

Back to the OP, I'm fairly sure it would make even shorter shift of the bottom half of your head Dogbot. ;)